Reengaging Students in Alternative Education: Belonging, Accountability, and a Way Forward
by: Kari Ehmer
When a student has fallen behind, stopped participating, or returned after a difficult stretch, the first conversation matters. They may already know the attendance numbers, the missing assignments, and the choices that brought them here. What they may not know is whether the adults around them still see a future for them.
Student reengagement starts with three things: a relationship that feels real, clear expectations, and one next step the student believes they can take. Alternative education and continuation school programs are often doing this work every day. The challenge is making those pieces consistent enough that students experience them, not just hear about them.
Find out what made school feel difficult to return to
A student who isn't showing up may be dealing with transportation, work, family responsibilities, conflict at school, discouragement, or several things at once. We lose useful information when we decide too quickly that a student simply doesn't care.
Try a brief check-in before the lecture: “What's been making it hard to get started?” Then listen long enough to hear the answer. You may not be able to solve every barrier, but you can make a more useful plan when you understand what is actually getting in the way.
Make belonging something students can experience
Belonging doesn't happen because a school puts the word on a poster. Students need opportunities to be known, contribute, and notice the people around them. That's why I use the phrase “Be Seen. See Others.” It asks students to think about both sides of connection.
A small practice staff can repeat
At the start of an advisory or small-group session, invite students to name one thing they want adults to understand about them and one way they can help someone else feel included. Give students a choice to write privately instead of sharing aloud. The point is to create a safe opening, not to force a personal story.
A consistent greeting, a check-in after an absence, and a chance to take a meaningful role in the group can matter as much as a big schoolwide event. Connection changes what comes next because it makes it easier for a student to ask for help and try again.
Separate the student from the mistake while keeping accountability
Some young people have heard so many versions of “troublemaker,” “behind,” or “not trying” that the label starts to feel permanent. A student still needs to own a harmful choice, repair what they can, and follow school expectations. They also need to believe their next choice matters.
One of the messages I want students to hear is: “You are not your biggest mistake.” The behavior deserves an honest conversation. The student's identity deserves more room than that one moment.
Try this conversation after a setback
“What happened?” “Who was affected?” “What part can you take responsibility for?” “What would a useful next step look like?”
Those questions give the student a way to participate in repair. They also give the adult a way to hold the line without turning the conversation into a judgment about who the student is. Formal restorative conferences and disciplinary decisions should still follow school policy and trained staff procedures.
Build confidence through one completed next step
When a student is behind in several classes, “get caught up” can sound impossible. A smaller action can help them experience progress today. That might mean attending the first 20 minutes of class, completing one missing task, meeting a counselor, or asking a teacher to help prioritize work.
I think of confidence as self-trust. It grows when students make a choice, follow through, and see that they can handle the next challenge. Start with a step the student can name clearly, then check back. The follow-up is what tells them the adult meant it.
Use Control the Controllables
Ask: “What's outside your control right now?” and “What's one thing you can control before tomorrow?” A student may not control a past grade or someone else's opinion. They can control whether they ask for help, show up for a conversation, or take the first step on an assignment. Keep the action specific enough to notice.
Teach a reset before the next hard moment
A student who is embarrassed, angry, or overwhelmed may know the right choice and still struggle to make it in the moment. Resetting is a skill that needs practice when things are calm, not only after something goes wrong.
A simple 60-Second Reset can look like this: pause and take a steady breath, notice what your inner voice is saying, then choose the next action you can control. Students might use a short phrase such as “I can take the next step” or “What can I do right now?” Let them choose language that feels believable to them.
This connects directly to the BE BOLD Framework: Engage Your Inner Voice, Be In Control, Own Your Choices, and Learn Through Failure. Students can practice those choices in ordinary classroom moments long before they face a bigger setback.
Give students a voice in the solution
Adults see attendance, grades, and behavior data. Students can explain the experience behind those numbers. Ask what helps them participate, what makes it harder, and what they would change about the way support is offered.
Student voice works best when the school closes the loop. If students identify a barrier, explain what the school can change, what it can't, and why. Even when the answer isn't yes, being taken seriously builds trust.
A 15-minute advisory routine to try
You don't need a complicated program to begin. A short, repeatable routine can help students practice connection and ownership:
Minutes 1–3: Welcome students by name and offer a quick, low-pressure check-in.
Minutes 4–6: Ask: “What's one thing that went well, and one thing that's been hard?” Allow a private written response.
Minutes 7–10: Have students identify one controllable action they can take before the next meeting.
Minutes 11–13: Invite an optional partner conversation about how to support someone else's next step.
Minutes 14–15: Close with a brief commitment and a plan for staff follow-up.
Keep the routine flexible for student needs and school policy. For a student in crisis or with significant unmet needs, connect them with the appropriate school support team rather than treating a mindset activity as a substitute for care.
Watch for signs of reengagement, not just a good session
A strong conversation is a start. Schools also need to know whether students are returning, participating, completing agreed-upon steps, and feeling more connected to adults and peers. Pair student feedback with attendance, coursework, and other indicators your school already monitors.
Resilience can be built. So can the belief that a setback doesn't decide the rest of your story. When schools make connection, responsibility, and next steps part of the daily experience, students have more chances to practice moving forward.
Bring these skills into your school community
My interactive school workshops give students time to practice the inner voice, reset routines, connection, and personal responsibility that help them respond when things get hard. Programs can be adapted for alternative education, continuation schools, and other student groups based on the school's goals and setting.
If your team is working to strengthen student belonging and reengagement, explore my school programs and let's talk about what would be most useful for your students.
About Kari

Kari Ehmer is a Confidence & Mindset Speaker and Coach who helps students, athletes, teams, and workplace leaders build belonging, confidence, and leadership, so they trust themselves when it matters most. A West Point graduate and Army veteran, she brings practical mindset tools to schools across Southern California through interactive assemblies, workshops, and multi-session programs. Learn more at kariehmer.com/speaking.




Comments